What do you think?
Rate this book
Chief Inspector Armand Gamache #13
Къщи от стъкло
Goodreads Choice Award
Nominee for Best Mystery & Thriller (2017)Когато черната фигура се появява на площада в Трите бора, местните смятат, че е просто шега. Но скоро любопитството им преминава в страх. Черното нещо сякаш не принадлежи на този свят. Около него се отваря дупка, която изсмуква радостта и смеха. А то просто стои. Часове наред. Неподвижно.
И гледа.
В мига, в който го вижда, Арман Гамаш решава, че маскираният е преоблечен като Смъртта. Уви, дори с властта на новия си пост – главен комисар в Sûreté, Гамаш не може да направи нищо. До мига, в който Смъртта наистина не навестява селцето.
Черната фигура изчезва, а на нейно място се появява труп.
Няколко месеца по-късно главният комисар е изправен на свидетелската банка в задушна съдебна зала в Монреал. Но делото за убийство е само част от много по-сложен процес. План, задействан от самия Гамаш и принудил го да пристъпи всеки закон, в който някога е вярвал. Целта е жизненоважна – и за Sûreté, и за жителите на Квебек. Въпросът е дали Гамаш ще успее да я постигне. Схемата, която е изградил, е тайна, невидима, естествена част от пейзажа наоколо – като къща от стъкло. Всяка грешна стъпка заплашва да я срути. А тогава Арман ще трябва да се изправи пред най-страшния съд – този на собствената си съвест.
Луиз Пени е канадска журналистка и писателка, която още с първия си роман от поредицата за инспектор Гамаш получава единайсет литературни награди, включително „Артър Елис“, „Бари“, „Антъни“ и „Дагър“. Пени е единствената в света седемкратна носителка на литературния приз „Агата Кристи“, а през 2013 г. е удостоена с Ордена на Канада за приноса й в литературата и канадската култура. Романите й са преведени на повече от трийсет езика и са издадени в многохилядни тиражи.
И гледа.
В мига, в който го вижда, Арман Гамаш решава, че маскираният е преоблечен като Смъртта. Уви, дори с властта на новия си пост – главен комисар в Sûreté, Гамаш не може да направи нищо. До мига, в който Смъртта наистина не навестява селцето.
Черната фигура изчезва, а на нейно място се появява труп.
Няколко месеца по-късно главният комисар е изправен на свидетелската банка в задушна съдебна зала в Монреал. Но делото за убийство е само част от много по-сложен процес. План, задействан от самия Гамаш и принудил го да пристъпи всеки закон, в който някога е вярвал. Целта е жизненоважна – и за Sûreté, и за жителите на Квебек. Въпросът е дали Гамаш ще успее да я постигне. Схемата, която е изградил, е тайна, невидима, естествена част от пейзажа наоколо – като къща от стъкло. Всяка грешна стъпка заплашва да я срути. А тогава Арман ще трябва да се изправи пред най-страшния съд – този на собствената си съвест.
Луиз Пени е канадска журналистка и писателка, която още с първия си роман от поредицата за инспектор Гамаш получава единайсет литературни награди, включително „Артър Елис“, „Бари“, „Антъни“ и „Дагър“. Пени е единствената в света седемкратна носителка на литературния приз „Агата Кристи“, а през 2013 г. е удостоена с Ордена на Канада за приноса й в литературата и канадската култура. Романите й са преведени на повече от трийсет езика и са издадени в многохилядни тиражи.
432 pages, Paperback
First published August 29, 2017
About the author
Louise Penny
49 books22.8k followersLOUISE PENNY is the author of the #1 New York Times and Globe and Mail bestselling series of Chief Inspector Armand Gamache novels. She has won numerous awards, including a CWA Dagger and the Agatha Award (seven times), and was a finalist for the Edgar Award for Best Novel. In 2017, she received the Order of Canada for her contributions to Canadian culture. Louise lives in a small village south of Montréal.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 6,690 reviews
February 24, 2018
5 🥐 🥐 🥐 🥐 🥐
So you’re a fan and you’re starting to get stressed.
How much longer can the author keep our hero sustainable?
Or perhaps you’re superstitious and thinking #13 could mean bad luck rather than a baker’s dozen.
How many murders can one small town suffer?
How many times can you enjoy a cafe au lait with a warm croissant dripping butter?
I know.
As long as she keeps writing we will continue to turn the pages and be hungry.
This one was exceptional, the best one yet; she’s taken it to a higher level—a higher love.
There was so much goodness inside, if it was a restaurant it would be awarded 3 Michelin stars. It even made me cry and that happens about as often as Ruth Zardo handing out a compliment.
Rest easy fans. In Three Pines the woods are lovely, dark and deep, and Armand Gamache has miles to go before he sleeps.
Merci Louise Penny. You are a wonder woman of an author.
Thanks also Minotaur Books & NetGalley for this ARC.
So you’re a fan and you’re starting to get stressed.
How much longer can the author keep our hero sustainable?
Or perhaps you’re superstitious and thinking #13 could mean bad luck rather than a baker’s dozen.
How many murders can one small town suffer?
How many times can you enjoy a cafe au lait with a warm croissant dripping butter?
I know.
As long as she keeps writing we will continue to turn the pages and be hungry.
This one was exceptional, the best one yet; she’s taken it to a higher level—a higher love.
There was so much goodness inside, if it was a restaurant it would be awarded 3 Michelin stars. It even made me cry and that happens about as often as Ruth Zardo handing out a compliment.
Rest easy fans. In Three Pines the woods are lovely, dark and deep, and Armand Gamache has miles to go before he sleeps.
Merci Louise Penny. You are a wonder woman of an author.
Thanks also Minotaur Books & NetGalley for this ARC.
June 3, 2017
The less said the better since I don't want to give anything away, so my review will be very brief. I will say fans of this series will not be disappointed, this one may well be the best so far. A hard thing to accomplish in series of this length. Gamache will put everything on the line. Something old will be mixed with a current scourge in many countries, has reached epidemic proportions, and is hurting and has hurt many. Ruth, my favorite, and her duck get a somewhat larger role and more of her poetry is quoted. It will all come down to who did what where and who knew what when. So, so good, very suspenseful and as always the characters of Three Pines will pull together. There is after all a great deal of love in this little town and a great deal of good. Remember to read the afterward, it is poignant and awe inspiring.
ARC from Netgalley.
Publishes August 29th by St. Martin's Press.
ARC from Netgalley.
Publishes August 29th by St. Martin's Press.
November 21, 2017
It pains me to do this, as this is one of my favorite series, but I can't give it more than 2.5 stars (fair).
With a new Penny book I settle in to spend time with my favorite characters in the quaint village of Three Pines. The books have always been as much of a character study as a mystery, and it’s one of the things I’ve loved about the series.
Unfortunately, this one just didn’t work for me. I didn’t care for the opioid epidemic theme, and although the book opens with a murder trial, the victim isn’t identified until well past 50%. I thought the constant switching from past to present, with the reader being kept in the dark, slowed things down to a crawl.
The quirky and lovable characters, as well as the cozy atmosphere in Three Pines, are missing. Even Gamache isn’t his typical self, he’s too full of angst and rather insufferable. The tone of the entire book just felt off. The other inhabitants of the village, especially Ruth, are in danger of becoming caricatures of their former selves.
There are several alternating story lines and the author does a fine job eventually merging them. The last 20% of the book was very enjoyable and was a reminder just what the residents of the village mean to one another. It was strong enough that I rounded my rating up.
I hope the next book brings us back to the Three Pines I know and love. The epilogue was heartfelt and touching, and was my favorite part of the book. Penny's husband, Michael, died from complications of Alzheimer's and writing this book was therapeutic for her. She has my sincere sympathy.
* many thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
With a new Penny book I settle in to spend time with my favorite characters in the quaint village of Three Pines. The books have always been as much of a character study as a mystery, and it’s one of the things I’ve loved about the series.
Unfortunately, this one just didn’t work for me. I didn’t care for the opioid epidemic theme, and although the book opens with a murder trial, the victim isn’t identified until well past 50%. I thought the constant switching from past to present, with the reader being kept in the dark, slowed things down to a crawl.
The quirky and lovable characters, as well as the cozy atmosphere in Three Pines, are missing. Even Gamache isn’t his typical self, he’s too full of angst and rather insufferable. The tone of the entire book just felt off. The other inhabitants of the village, especially Ruth, are in danger of becoming caricatures of their former selves.
There are several alternating story lines and the author does a fine job eventually merging them. The last 20% of the book was very enjoyable and was a reminder just what the residents of the village mean to one another. It was strong enough that I rounded my rating up.
I hope the next book brings us back to the Three Pines I know and love. The epilogue was heartfelt and touching, and was my favorite part of the book. Penny's husband, Michael, died from complications of Alzheimer's and writing this book was therapeutic for her. She has my sincere sympathy.
* many thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
August 2, 2017
No murder. No Gamache.
The Cobrador: A tall, hooded figure robed in the midnight hour of black takes its position in the village center of Three Pines. The chilled November wind swirls around this individual who neither moves nor gestures to another soul.
High in the Pyrenees in 1841 a cobrador's presence signified a debt to be collected. Who is the cobrador eyeing for the recompense of something owed? And is it in the vein of money due or a kettle of moral debt never repaid?
Armand Gamache, Chief Inspector of the Surete du Quebec, is seated among his friends in the quiet window area of the cafe. He's already been out to confront the dark forboding figure who stands erect and wordless. No crime committed. No reason for arrest. At least, not today.
But when Reine-Marie Gamache, Armand's wife, discovers a body in the church basement, the village is met with a tidal wave of accusations that hit the wall over and over again. Who is responsible and does the trail lead to the cobrador? Is anyone safe from the guilt laid upon them for what they perceive as their own debts?
Louise Penny has more incredible story frames locked within her mind than there are grapes in the Tuscany countryside. Once again, she gathers the familiar Three Pines' hearts and brings them together entwined in a plot of murder, guilt, familiarity, historic trails, and the pursuit of law against the lawless.
Penny sets this stage with quite an original flavor. The story opens with Gamache on the stand in the heat of July being endlessly questioned about the murder that took place the previous November. We, the readers, do not know the individual held for this heinous act. She also weaves a secondary level of intrigue with Gamache and his son-in-law, Jean-Guy, monitoring a heavy duty drug bust involving the sale of opioids. The endless battle with drugs is one that forces Gamache to look into the dark eyes of nearing defeat. "Admitting you are afraid takes courage."
If you are a long time fan of the Gamache series or even if you have newly arrived, please savor Penny's words in the Author's Note. Her previous book, A Great Reckoning, is my favorite of all. But oh, dear reader, this one sits right alongside it. Louise Penny knows how to touch your inner spirit....because she's been there and continues to leave a lasting imprint that is timeless.
I received a copy of Glass Houses through NetGalley for an honest review. My sincere appreciation to Minotaur Books and to Louise Penny for the opportunity.
The Cobrador: A tall, hooded figure robed in the midnight hour of black takes its position in the village center of Three Pines. The chilled November wind swirls around this individual who neither moves nor gestures to another soul.
High in the Pyrenees in 1841 a cobrador's presence signified a debt to be collected. Who is the cobrador eyeing for the recompense of something owed? And is it in the vein of money due or a kettle of moral debt never repaid?
Armand Gamache, Chief Inspector of the Surete du Quebec, is seated among his friends in the quiet window area of the cafe. He's already been out to confront the dark forboding figure who stands erect and wordless. No crime committed. No reason for arrest. At least, not today.
But when Reine-Marie Gamache, Armand's wife, discovers a body in the church basement, the village is met with a tidal wave of accusations that hit the wall over and over again. Who is responsible and does the trail lead to the cobrador? Is anyone safe from the guilt laid upon them for what they perceive as their own debts?
Louise Penny has more incredible story frames locked within her mind than there are grapes in the Tuscany countryside. Once again, she gathers the familiar Three Pines' hearts and brings them together entwined in a plot of murder, guilt, familiarity, historic trails, and the pursuit of law against the lawless.
Penny sets this stage with quite an original flavor. The story opens with Gamache on the stand in the heat of July being endlessly questioned about the murder that took place the previous November. We, the readers, do not know the individual held for this heinous act. She also weaves a secondary level of intrigue with Gamache and his son-in-law, Jean-Guy, monitoring a heavy duty drug bust involving the sale of opioids. The endless battle with drugs is one that forces Gamache to look into the dark eyes of nearing defeat. "Admitting you are afraid takes courage."
If you are a long time fan of the Gamache series or even if you have newly arrived, please savor Penny's words in the Author's Note. Her previous book, A Great Reckoning, is my favorite of all. But oh, dear reader, this one sits right alongside it. Louise Penny knows how to touch your inner spirit....because she's been there and continues to leave a lasting imprint that is timeless.
I received a copy of Glass Houses through NetGalley for an honest review. My sincere appreciation to Minotaur Books and to Louise Penny for the opportunity.
February 16, 2023
Glass Houses (Chief Inspector Gamache #13)
by Louise Penny, Robert Bathurst (Narrator)
In book thirteen of the Chief Inspector Armand Gamache series there is a trial. There is that timeline but we also see things that happened before the trial and things that happen after the trial, with all three timelines interspersed throughout the book. This was the most confusing story in the series for me although I did enjoy the story despite my confusion.
The story has several threads that may or may not meet up by the end. There is the The Cobrador, a hooded, mysterious figure that has started standing in Three Pines' village center. The entire village is disturbed by this dark figure and want it gone. But whoever is under those robes has done nothing wrong so Gamache does nothing either. There are also some long time visitors to Three Pines who usually visit during the warmer months but instead are here in the darker, fall months. Something is not right with them on this visit. And then there is the very big and evil thing that is hanging over the story, a thing that involves cartels, drugs, death for everyone in one way or another. This big thing is impossible to stop but Gamache must stop it or all will be doomed.
This story had me confused a good part of the time because of the three main timelines: the trial, before the trial, and after the trial. Maybe in the print version it might be easy to tell when there is a timeline change but it wasn't obvious to me so I had trouble knowing the timeline in the before and after trial parts of the story. I did like getting to listen to Penny and Bathurst talk about their work, once the actual story had ended, and I appreciate Penny telling us how she works, including the mention of the structure of this story. Some things she does confuse me and I accept that and still enjoy the stories immensely. Also, Bathurst is as much Gamache as Ralph Cosham was for the first ten books, he has won me over, job well done!
Published August 29, 2017
by Louise Penny, Robert Bathurst (Narrator)
In book thirteen of the Chief Inspector Armand Gamache series there is a trial. There is that timeline but we also see things that happened before the trial and things that happen after the trial, with all three timelines interspersed throughout the book. This was the most confusing story in the series for me although I did enjoy the story despite my confusion.
The story has several threads that may or may not meet up by the end. There is the The Cobrador, a hooded, mysterious figure that has started standing in Three Pines' village center. The entire village is disturbed by this dark figure and want it gone. But whoever is under those robes has done nothing wrong so Gamache does nothing either. There are also some long time visitors to Three Pines who usually visit during the warmer months but instead are here in the darker, fall months. Something is not right with them on this visit. And then there is the very big and evil thing that is hanging over the story, a thing that involves cartels, drugs, death for everyone in one way or another. This big thing is impossible to stop but Gamache must stop it or all will be doomed.
This story had me confused a good part of the time because of the three main timelines: the trial, before the trial, and after the trial. Maybe in the print version it might be easy to tell when there is a timeline change but it wasn't obvious to me so I had trouble knowing the timeline in the before and after trial parts of the story. I did like getting to listen to Penny and Bathurst talk about their work, once the actual story had ended, and I appreciate Penny telling us how she works, including the mention of the structure of this story. Some things she does confuse me and I accept that and still enjoy the stories immensely. Also, Bathurst is as much Gamache as Ralph Cosham was for the first ten books, he has won me over, job well done!
Published August 29, 2017
September 29, 2017
In this installment of the Inspector Gamache series, he tackles the drug cartels and the fentanyl crisis (which we are reminded frequently kills 50 people for every kilo sold) all out of the seemingly peaceful sanctity of Three Pines. Meanwhile, a disturbing, hooded figure takes up residence on the Village Green and silently stares, bringing a sense of forboding to the sleepy town. Modeled after a Cobrador, or Conscience with a capital C, everyone in the Village feels certain it has come for them.
This is a hard review to write. I’m a huge Louise Penny fan - I loved the first 11 books in the Inspector Gamache series and eagerly preordered the 12th, pouncing on it as soon as it arrived. Perhaps those high expectations are part of why I found this book so absolutely dreadful. Had it been any other author I would have stopped reading after the first couple of chapters. The writing is simply bad. It reads like a first draft. Characters that I loved, that had wonderful depth in previous books, have become caricatures of themselves. I literally do not like these people any more.
The structure is a big part of the problem. The book opens at the murder trial with Gamache on the witness stand. We don’t find out who was actually murdered until 50% of the way through the book. It is 75% of the way through the book before we find out who the accused murderer is. There is very little action (until the very end) and the dramatic tension is maintained not by what is happening but by what we as readers aren’t told. Multiple chapters end with Gamache and Beauvoir looking at a new piece of startling information and exchanging serious looks - but the reader isn’t let in on the secret. About 60% of the book alternates between repetitious hand-wringing (about the drug crisis, the scary guy on the green, or Gamache’s approach (or apparent lack of approach) to solving the problem) and bland filler about food and drink (and by the way, for a novel focussed on how terrible the drug crisis is, our heroes drink A LOT!). That is just sloppy writing!
The last chapters in the book, where the action finally comes to a head, reminds me of the old Louise Penny. I enjoyed reading that, but it in no way made up for the hours I spent slogging through the rest. I know that Ms Penny’s husband died, and I know that writing was her escape during a very, very, difficult time and I feel bad giving it a bad review, but I can’t pretend something is good when it is really very, very bad! I wish she had gone back and and done some editing before releasing. I will certainly give her the benefit of the doubt and give the next book (if there is a next book) a try, but this book was truly awful.
I really don't understand why so many people rated this so highly!
This is a hard review to write. I’m a huge Louise Penny fan - I loved the first 11 books in the Inspector Gamache series and eagerly preordered the 12th, pouncing on it as soon as it arrived. Perhaps those high expectations are part of why I found this book so absolutely dreadful. Had it been any other author I would have stopped reading after the first couple of chapters. The writing is simply bad. It reads like a first draft. Characters that I loved, that had wonderful depth in previous books, have become caricatures of themselves. I literally do not like these people any more.
The structure is a big part of the problem. The book opens at the murder trial with Gamache on the witness stand. We don’t find out who was actually murdered until 50% of the way through the book. It is 75% of the way through the book before we find out who the accused murderer is. There is very little action (until the very end) and the dramatic tension is maintained not by what is happening but by what we as readers aren’t told. Multiple chapters end with Gamache and Beauvoir looking at a new piece of startling information and exchanging serious looks - but the reader isn’t let in on the secret. About 60% of the book alternates between repetitious hand-wringing (about the drug crisis, the scary guy on the green, or Gamache’s approach (or apparent lack of approach) to solving the problem) and bland filler about food and drink (and by the way, for a novel focussed on how terrible the drug crisis is, our heroes drink A LOT!). That is just sloppy writing!
The last chapters in the book, where the action finally comes to a head, reminds me of the old Louise Penny. I enjoyed reading that, but it in no way made up for the hours I spent slogging through the rest. I know that Ms Penny’s husband died, and I know that writing was her escape during a very, very, difficult time and I feel bad giving it a bad review, but I can’t pretend something is good when it is really very, very bad! I wish she had gone back and and done some editing before releasing. I will certainly give her the benefit of the doubt and give the next book (if there is a next book) a try, but this book was truly awful.
I really don't understand why so many people rated this so highly!
September 11, 2017
"There is a higher court than courts of justice and that is the court of conscience. It supersedes all other courts." ~Gandhi
In this 13th book of Louise Penny’s “Inspector Gamache” series, the peaceful village of Three Pines is being threatened by something menacing. A tall figure stands still and silent in the village square wearing a black robe and black mask. Menacing just by virtue of its dark presence, like a personification of Death itself.
The stories of the cobrador of Spain tell of a person wearing dark clothing and a top hat following a debtor around until they are shamed into paying what is owed. The author adds a dimension to this and the figure in this story becomes one of Conscience rather than debt. A reminder that we all have, or should have, a conscience to guide us toward right action.
A group of friends is on their annual visit to the village and one of them is murdered. The majority of this well-paced novel unfolds during the trial of the murderer with flash backs to actual events elaborating on Chief Superintendent Gamache’s testimony in response to the Crown Prosecutor’s questions.
Armand Gamache is now the head of the entire Surete and in his capacity of Chief Superintendent he has launched a final battle strategy in the war on crime - specifically the drug cartels whose products directly feed into almost all other crimes. The risks he is taking are huge and there are no guarantees that things will work out according to plan.
This is one of Louise Penny’s best novels in the series so far – and that is saying something, as I have loved every one of them!
In this 13th book of Louise Penny’s “Inspector Gamache” series, the peaceful village of Three Pines is being threatened by something menacing. A tall figure stands still and silent in the village square wearing a black robe and black mask. Menacing just by virtue of its dark presence, like a personification of Death itself.
The stories of the cobrador of Spain tell of a person wearing dark clothing and a top hat following a debtor around until they are shamed into paying what is owed. The author adds a dimension to this and the figure in this story becomes one of Conscience rather than debt. A reminder that we all have, or should have, a conscience to guide us toward right action.
A group of friends is on their annual visit to the village and one of them is murdered. The majority of this well-paced novel unfolds during the trial of the murderer with flash backs to actual events elaborating on Chief Superintendent Gamache’s testimony in response to the Crown Prosecutor’s questions.
Armand Gamache is now the head of the entire Surete and in his capacity of Chief Superintendent he has launched a final battle strategy in the war on crime - specifically the drug cartels whose products directly feed into almost all other crimes. The risks he is taking are huge and there are no guarantees that things will work out according to plan.
This is one of Louise Penny’s best novels in the series so far – and that is saying something, as I have loved every one of them!
November 19, 2017
What a disappointment. I’ve enjoyed this series from the start but the last two books have been so far fetched. The previous book was about the small town, Three Pines, finding a huge war cannon in their forest, and Glass Houses, is about conscience. I dislike it when a series goes way off the mark and steers into different territory. I just want to read about a good old murder and listen to Gamache quote some poetry.
3 out of 5 stars.
3 out of 5 stars.
September 6, 2017
4.5 stars rounded up to 5 stars.
It's that time of year again, Armand. Labour Day weekend, and we get to spend a couple of days together...
Last year, I went gaga over Louise Penny's annual dose of Armand Gamache and the folks in Three Pines. This year's fare was lovely, but I can't quite give it five stars because I didn't love the end. But, still, I remain a true fan, wishing I could stumble onto the village of Three Pines, have a croissant and cafe au lait at the bistro while meeting my favourite characters and trying not to blush when shaking Armand's hand -- and trying to keep out of death's path.
I absolutely loved the set up of this year's book. Starting in a court room in Montreal, with Armand as a witness, Penny depicts the minutiae of a trial dealing with a murder that took place several months earlier -- I love good courtroom dramas so this aspect of the book was a real treat for me. The story moves back and forth in time from the appearance of a strange dark figure in Three Pines, slowly revealing what happened after its appearance, while connecting those events to the tension of the trial in Montreal. The dark figure turns out to be a brilliant device. And Penny introduces a new character I really enjoyed -- Maureen Corriveau who is the judge presiding over the trial.
I can't say more about the plot because the way in which this one unfolds is masterful and it would be a shame to ruin the effect. I will only say that the only part I didn't love was how the end gets resolved. But my enthusiasm for this series is not in the least diminished. I continue to be awed by how Penny mixes great characters with interesting and important issues, always engaging my emotions, intellect and moral compass.
And, again this year, Penny managed to make me teary with her afterword. Her husband, Michael who is the model for Armand's personality, died of complications from Alzheimer's in September last year. She talks about him with such grace and love. I am awed that she was able to complete this book while grieving, and appreciate that writing is her escape.
So, Armand, I feel the fall coming. School starts tomorrow. It's Labour Day. It feels like it's time to pull my socks up and get back into the busy rhythm of work and home life. It's time to part once more. Thanks again for allowing me to spend time with you and your family in Three Pines this weekend. You've recharged my batteries. I'll see you next year, and in the meantime please make sure to get into more interesting trouble while keeping safe...
Sigh...
It's that time of year again, Armand. Labour Day weekend, and we get to spend a couple of days together...
Last year, I went gaga over Louise Penny's annual dose of Armand Gamache and the folks in Three Pines. This year's fare was lovely, but I can't quite give it five stars because I didn't love the end. But, still, I remain a true fan, wishing I could stumble onto the village of Three Pines, have a croissant and cafe au lait at the bistro while meeting my favourite characters and trying not to blush when shaking Armand's hand -- and trying to keep out of death's path.
I absolutely loved the set up of this year's book. Starting in a court room in Montreal, with Armand as a witness, Penny depicts the minutiae of a trial dealing with a murder that took place several months earlier -- I love good courtroom dramas so this aspect of the book was a real treat for me. The story moves back and forth in time from the appearance of a strange dark figure in Three Pines, slowly revealing what happened after its appearance, while connecting those events to the tension of the trial in Montreal. The dark figure turns out to be a brilliant device. And Penny introduces a new character I really enjoyed -- Maureen Corriveau who is the judge presiding over the trial.
I can't say more about the plot because the way in which this one unfolds is masterful and it would be a shame to ruin the effect. I will only say that the only part I didn't love was how the end gets resolved. But my enthusiasm for this series is not in the least diminished. I continue to be awed by how Penny mixes great characters with interesting and important issues, always engaging my emotions, intellect and moral compass.
And, again this year, Penny managed to make me teary with her afterword. Her husband, Michael who is the model for Armand's personality, died of complications from Alzheimer's in September last year. She talks about him with such grace and love. I am awed that she was able to complete this book while grieving, and appreciate that writing is her escape.
So, Armand, I feel the fall coming. School starts tomorrow. It's Labour Day. It feels like it's time to pull my socks up and get back into the busy rhythm of work and home life. It's time to part once more. Thanks again for allowing me to spend time with you and your family in Three Pines this weekend. You've recharged my batteries. I'll see you next year, and in the meantime please make sure to get into more interesting trouble while keeping safe...
Sigh...
November 7, 2022
Finally...my overdue visit to Three Pines!
I’ve loved this series from the beginning. But with so many new authors and amazing reads available, I’ve fallen behind. So…I decided to try the audio version to give me a boost.
A surprisingly different experience! Putting voices to characters you’ve imagined over the years. I thought Gamache's character was represented perfectly, the voice and tone suiting him to a T.
But once the narrator added voices to other characters of Three Pines I stumbled, needing to ‘reroute’ my imagination. It felt similar to watching the movie after you’ve finished the book..🤷🏻♀️(Which I never do!)
Chief Superintendent of the Sûreté du Quebec, Armand Gamache is in court giving testimony in a murder trial. He’s the prosecutor’s star witness. Yet they seem to be battling each other. Why? What could they possibly hope to achieve by not working together?
I enjoyed my long overdue visit to Three Pines and it’s eclectic inhabitants. I believe I’ll stay with the audio versions until I catch up in the series.
Thank you to my local library 🎧
I’ve loved this series from the beginning. But with so many new authors and amazing reads available, I’ve fallen behind. So…I decided to try the audio version to give me a boost.
A surprisingly different experience! Putting voices to characters you’ve imagined over the years. I thought Gamache's character was represented perfectly, the voice and tone suiting him to a T.
But once the narrator added voices to other characters of Three Pines I stumbled, needing to ‘reroute’ my imagination. It felt similar to watching the movie after you’ve finished the book..🤷🏻♀️(Which I never do!)
Chief Superintendent of the Sûreté du Quebec, Armand Gamache is in court giving testimony in a murder trial. He’s the prosecutor’s star witness. Yet they seem to be battling each other. Why? What could they possibly hope to achieve by not working together?
I enjoyed my long overdue visit to Three Pines and it’s eclectic inhabitants. I believe I’ll stay with the audio versions until I catch up in the series.
Thank you to my local library 🎧
November 9, 2018
Louise Penny continues to impress with new and exciting story angles to enrich this already alluring series. Fans of these novels will surely find something here to whet their appetites or at least provide something with which they can relate. On the night of the Three Pines Hallowe’en celebration, many of the townsfolk notice a mysterious figure dressed in black. He stands in the town square, not speaking, but his menacing glare cannot be missed. Soon identified as a cobrador del frac, this man serves as a debt collector, though he does not speak, which only adds to the mystery. Which townsperson might he be here to see and what have they done? Cobradors are common in Spain as a last ditch effort to shame a person into settling their debts, but their more historic service has been as a conscience to push a person to see their error and do right, all without uttering a word. When Katie Evans is found murdered in the church basement, dressed in the cobrador outfit, many wonder who might have done this and whether the mysterious man could be responsible and have fled the scene. Newly promoted Chief Superintendent Armand Gamache seeks to better understand the entire situation, particularly since he now resides in Three Pines. However, his attention is divided between this and a major covert operation being undertaken by senior members of the Sûreté du Québec, seeking to bring down a major drug cartel. This will be extremely delicate and require much patience, with each decision potentially blowing their cover. In an odd turn of events, the narrative splits between these storylines in the past and a trial for the murder of Katie Evans, with Gamache on the stand and seeming to work with the Crown to bring down an unknown defendant. As the story unfolds, the Three Pines residents learn more about what Evans might have done to require such a mysterious guest. It also permits each resident to look inside themselves to explore their own faults and what they might be able to do differently; almost as if they were peering into their own glass house. Definitely a unique reading experience as I see things from a variety of perspectives, which only goes to show that Penny does not want her readers resting on their laurels. I would highly recommend this book to series fans who have a great handle on the characters and writing style. Readers new to Penny’s series ought to begin where the stories began and progress accordingly.
I have finally completed this major Louise Penny binge, reading her entire collection of Gamache novels that have been released, with one more set to land on my iPod in the coming weeks. I have come to see a great deal of development in the series, both in the settings—particularly Three Pines—and the characters, especially Armand Gamache, the constant protagonist. Some readers have been critical of such a major undertaking, reading/breathing nothing but Armand Gamache for an extended period. They comment that it only serves to supersaturate me with his quirks, though I found the undertaking quite sobering. I noticed a few of the series nuances lost to the reader who relies on annual instalments of the progress all characters make. While Gamache spent much of his time in this series as the Chief Inspector of Homicide, where he led one of the most prestigious teams in the country, his personal growth emanates from the pages of each novel. Through some significant turmoil, he left the Sûreté du Québec, as series readers will know well, an inner fight between professional decisions and personal sentiment. Returning to the fold in the last two novels, Gamache has shown that he is a quintessential part of the police force and, while some still see him as a major disturbance, he is the one needed to steer it back into calm waters. Gamache proves to be a leader who may not be sullied with corruption, but whose record remains somewhat unimpressive. He seeks not only to continue delivering sage advice, but also use stern leadership skills to keep his subordinates in line. He has grown significantly throughout the series and this novel is no exception. Gamache connects well with the reader, though there is always some degree of distance the protagonist demands with each developing narrative. Other characters of note include the recurring townsfolk of Three Pines, each with their quirks and hilarious banter. I have come to love some of them and await the disappearance of others. One cannot make it through a book in the series without at least one squabble between two of these unique characters, though it lightens the mood as the reader is usually ensconced in some deeper mystery at the time. Jean Guy Beauvoir is back, working alongside Gamache, while continuing to grow as a worthwhile son-in-law and battling his own recovery from significant addiction. I have come to see much growth in him as well, though I sense that he petered out a few novels ago, perhaps Penny’s way of punishing him for being so judgmental. The story here was quite unique and held my attention throughout. The title perfectly parallels some of the themes within the book and keeps the reader wanting to know a little more before reaching the climax and complete reveal. While I have come to the end of the binge, I can see great things for Penny, should she continue the series well into the future. It is a stunning Canadian police procedural that mixes great writing with poignant Canadian references, which warms the soul. I am so pleased I undertook the journey and am eager to continue later this month with the latest instalment. While I said it before, highest recommendations for anyone seeking to delve into a well-crafted series that does not disappoint most readers.
Kudos, Madam Penny, for allowing me to be fully committed throughout the series. This is a binge I will not soon forget or regret!
Like/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
A Book for All Seasons, a different sort of Book Challenge: https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/...
I have finally completed this major Louise Penny binge, reading her entire collection of Gamache novels that have been released, with one more set to land on my iPod in the coming weeks. I have come to see a great deal of development in the series, both in the settings—particularly Three Pines—and the characters, especially Armand Gamache, the constant protagonist. Some readers have been critical of such a major undertaking, reading/breathing nothing but Armand Gamache for an extended period. They comment that it only serves to supersaturate me with his quirks, though I found the undertaking quite sobering. I noticed a few of the series nuances lost to the reader who relies on annual instalments of the progress all characters make. While Gamache spent much of his time in this series as the Chief Inspector of Homicide, where he led one of the most prestigious teams in the country, his personal growth emanates from the pages of each novel. Through some significant turmoil, he left the Sûreté du Québec, as series readers will know well, an inner fight between professional decisions and personal sentiment. Returning to the fold in the last two novels, Gamache has shown that he is a quintessential part of the police force and, while some still see him as a major disturbance, he is the one needed to steer it back into calm waters. Gamache proves to be a leader who may not be sullied with corruption, but whose record remains somewhat unimpressive. He seeks not only to continue delivering sage advice, but also use stern leadership skills to keep his subordinates in line. He has grown significantly throughout the series and this novel is no exception. Gamache connects well with the reader, though there is always some degree of distance the protagonist demands with each developing narrative. Other characters of note include the recurring townsfolk of Three Pines, each with their quirks and hilarious banter. I have come to love some of them and await the disappearance of others. One cannot make it through a book in the series without at least one squabble between two of these unique characters, though it lightens the mood as the reader is usually ensconced in some deeper mystery at the time. Jean Guy Beauvoir is back, working alongside Gamache, while continuing to grow as a worthwhile son-in-law and battling his own recovery from significant addiction. I have come to see much growth in him as well, though I sense that he petered out a few novels ago, perhaps Penny’s way of punishing him for being so judgmental. The story here was quite unique and held my attention throughout. The title perfectly parallels some of the themes within the book and keeps the reader wanting to know a little more before reaching the climax and complete reveal. While I have come to the end of the binge, I can see great things for Penny, should she continue the series well into the future. It is a stunning Canadian police procedural that mixes great writing with poignant Canadian references, which warms the soul. I am so pleased I undertook the journey and am eager to continue later this month with the latest instalment. While I said it before, highest recommendations for anyone seeking to delve into a well-crafted series that does not disappoint most readers.
Kudos, Madam Penny, for allowing me to be fully committed throughout the series. This is a binge I will not soon forget or regret!
Like/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
A Book for All Seasons, a different sort of Book Challenge: https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/...
April 1, 2018
It’s All Saints Day and a person robed all in black appears in the center of Three Pines. Speaking to no one, he just stands. What is he meant to represent?
Penny’s work is always convoluted. This time, maybe more than previously. Scenes flip back and forth between a court case where you don’t even know the defendant is and the time leading forward from the figure arriving in Three Pines.
This isn’t just about a murder though. Gamache, in his new role as chief Superintendent of the Surete, is going after the major drug cartel in Quebec. He’s playing a very dangerous game, trying to win the war, not the small battles.
The writing, as always, is perfect. Her mysteries are deeper than most. There’s always a bit of philosophy at work. The biggest question is always why a murder was committed, not who committed it. And here, there’s the added question of how things will play out against the drug cartel and what will be the cost.
I love returning to these characters; getting to know them a little better each time. I adore Ruth and Rosa, but each one is fully three dimensional. Make sure to read the author’s note at the end.
An enjoyable, engrossing read.
September 16, 2017
I was disappointed in the first half of this book. There are strangers in Three Pines. Anton is a dishwasher working in the bistro, and Jacqueline works in the boulangerie even though her talent does not include making baguettes. There are also two married couples, including Lea who has known Myrna since childhood. They have annually visited Three Pines for a few years. This will not be the wonderful visit with old friends that I expect.
There is a Cobrador, a masked, black-robed and -hooded figure standing on the village green hour after hour, day after day. Chief Inspector Armand Gamache says the figure is doing nothing illegal. The villagers are nervous and afraid, and children are not outside playing. A mob threatens the figure. Then a body is found. All this makes me feel unsettled. What is happening to this quaint little village?
Gamache sits in a witness box testifying for the prosecution in a murder case, yet he and the Chief Crown Prosecutor seem to be adversaries. There is some grand plan, something going on that's not quite right. Everything feels vague, shrouded in secrecy, and I'm not privy to very much.
So, yes, it's fair to say I was not a happy reader. The writing felt choppy with too many short, incomplete sentences. Phrases really. Words. That began to irritate me a bit. I was even getting irritated with Rosa the duck, fer cryin’ out loud! I asked the author, “Who are you, and what have you done with Louise Penny?” Then Penny picks up the pace and hits her stride in the second half. The final 15% was speed-reading! I don't think this is Louise Penny at her best. I knew and understand her circumstances as she spells them out in her Acknowledgment. My conclusion: Not a 5, but not a 3, either. Still one of my favorite authors and series.
There is a Cobrador, a masked, black-robed and -hooded figure standing on the village green hour after hour, day after day. Chief Inspector Armand Gamache says the figure is doing nothing illegal. The villagers are nervous and afraid, and children are not outside playing. A mob threatens the figure. Then a body is found. All this makes me feel unsettled. What is happening to this quaint little village?
Gamache sits in a witness box testifying for the prosecution in a murder case, yet he and the Chief Crown Prosecutor seem to be adversaries. There is some grand plan, something going on that's not quite right. Everything feels vague, shrouded in secrecy, and I'm not privy to very much.
So, yes, it's fair to say I was not a happy reader. The writing felt choppy with too many short, incomplete sentences. Phrases really. Words. That began to irritate me a bit. I was even getting irritated with Rosa the duck, fer cryin’ out loud! I asked the author, “Who are you, and what have you done with Louise Penny?” Then Penny picks up the pace and hits her stride in the second half. The final 15% was speed-reading! I don't think this is Louise Penny at her best. I knew and understand her circumstances as she spells them out in her Acknowledgment. My conclusion: Not a 5, but not a 3, either. Still one of my favorite authors and series.
December 4, 2021
3.5 stars
In this 13th book in the 'Chief Inspector Armand Gamache' series, the detective is trying to destroy a drug cartel. The book can be read as a standalone.
*****
Armand Gamache is now Chief Superintendent of the Sûreté du Québec, which he's spent years ridding of entrenched corruption. The Chief Superintendent is now fighting another battle - aimed at containing the drug epidemic that's ruining (or ending) so many lives.
Gamache is coordinating much of the drug war from the village of 'Three Pines', located beside the Canada-Vermont border....
......where Gamache lives with his wife Reine-Marie;
German Shepherd Henri;
and new dog Gracie - who looks like a cross between a canine and a rabbit. 😊
Gamache's plans to take down the drug cartel - which MUST be kept top secret - are thrown off kilter after a mysterious figure draws attention to Three Pines. One day a masked, black-clad individual shows up at a Halloween party, after which the figure takes up a position in the center of town - not speaking, not moving.....only staring. Though the statue-like figure doesn't say a word, one can almost sense it thinking "J'ACCUSE." The creepy individual isn't an overt threat, so - though it makes the townsfolk VERY uncomfortable - there's nothing Gamache can do about it.
A group of Université de Montréal graduates, who are having a reunion of sorts in Three Pines, know something about what the figure represents - but they're reluctant to say anything.
Information about the spooky symbol IS slowly revealed to Gamache, but not before a murder occurs.....and Reine-Marie discovers the body.
A suspect confesses to the crime, and is put on trial. However the trial is a tricky undertaking since it might alert the drug cartel to how much Gamache knows about them. So, the Chief Inspector is in the tough spot of deciding whether or not to commit perjury!! 😵 To add to the drama, the Chief Crown Prosecutor Barry Zalmanowitz - who should be on the same side as Gamache - is hostile and antagonistic.
The book alternates between the trial, the events leading up to it, and the implementation of Gamache's plan to destroy the drug cartel - so there are time jumps, but the story is easy to follow.
The usual recurring characters are on hand, including: Jean-Guy Beauvoir - Gamache's son-in-law and second in command at the Sûreté;
Oliver and Gabri - who run the local B&B/bistro and host the visiting university alumni;
Myrna - who runs the bookstore and will trade drinks for scuttlebutt about the murder inquiry;
Clara - the portrait artist who mostly paints (half-finished) pictures of herself;
the ornery old poet Ruth and her duck Rosa 🦆 - who tend to sound alike (quack quack); and more.
There are also some new faces in the story, such as: Judge Maureen Corriveau - who's in charge of the murder trial, and senses something's wrong; Anton - the new dishwasher at the bistro, who aspires to be a chef; Jaqueline - a baker who creates good pastries but can't make a decent baguette; and others.
I enjoyed the book, which is well-written and compelling. However, I think the premise - about the crucial need to derail the Québec based drug cartel - is disingenuous. The destruction of a drug gang, even if it's successful, isn't going to end the drug epidemic. Narcotics cartels are like Hydras - cut off one head and another one grows. So Gamache's long-term plan to decimate the drug organization - which causes tremendous hardship in the Sûreté and in Québec - doesn't ring true.
Still, this is a well-crafted novel that I'd recommend to readers who like mysteries - especially fans of Armand Gamache.
You can follow my reviews at https://reviewsbybarbsaffer.blogspot....
September 1, 2020
4.5
“And that’s what the chief explored. Elusive, volatile, unpredictable, often dangerous feelings. Searching out that one raw, wild emotion. That led to murder.”
Two timelines over two seasons, one during late autumn in the small Canadian village of Three Pines, and one in the sweltering summer of a Montreal courtroom with broken air conditioning. Louise Penny does the heat of a summer's day in close quarters as well as she does blustery cold in a remote, dark forest at night.
The book opens in a hot, crowded, Montreal courtroom:
“‘State your name, please.’
‘Armand Gamache.’
‘And you are the head of the Sûreté du Québec?’
‘The Chief Superintendent, oui.’ ”
Gamache has risen to the top of the Québec police force, which he has just cleaned out and is gradually restaffing. He thinks they have almost completely lost the War Against Drugs, as it is so often called, and he despairs for the thousands of families who are being torn apart as their children succumb to Fentanyl and the like.
He is determined to make a last-ditch effort to blow up the cartels. So why is he on the witness stand being questioned in a hostile manner by the Chief Crown Prosecutor?
Penny has chosen not to write this as a dual timeline or with alternating chapters. In answer to a question on Goodreads, she says:
“I didn’t want to fall into the easy formula of having one chapter past, next in the present. I wanted it to feel like it does in real life….where we often have our minds in both places. Standing in the present but reliving the past. Without a border. Slipping back and forth.”
https://www.goodreads.com/notes/34223...
So why is Gamache testifying and to what? His mind goes back to the previous autumn in Three Pines, the tiny village to which he and his beloved wife, Reine-Marie, have retired. Retired until he took up this new position, that is. He discovered it when investigating a murder many years ago.
“Few could find Three Pines, hidden in the valley, and that included the satellites that provided Internet coverage for most of the planet. The village was civilization adjacent. The information superhighway zoomed overhead. And Three Pines was a pothole.”
Readers of previous books in the series know the charm of Three Pines and the community of which so many of us have become fond. And the food, which we all drool over. Our favourite characters are there, along with some newcomers – an assistant at the bakery and a guy who fancies himself a chef but who’s washing dishes in the bistro.
Then there’s a group of friends who usually holiday here together in the summer but have moved their visit to autumn. One is a well-known politician now, but all have been friends since university days.
The Three Pines section begins on Halloween, October 31, at a party, where a strange figure has appeared and then disappeared. Whoever it was wore a dark coat with a hood up in such a way that nobody noticed the face. Later, the figure just stood still in the Village Green for hours on end, seemingly haunting ‘someone’ by simply standing and staring in a particular direction.
We’re told a story about the possible significance of this stalking, but nobody has any idea what the purpose is or who the target is. It does appear to suggest that someone who has been wronged is seeking retribution. A kind of living conscience.
Ruth is a cranky, foul-mouthed 80-year-old, who is also a poet. Occasionally we are treated to a bit of it, and these few lines are quoted more than once.
This pricks the consciences of some of the men, who muse privately about the choices they’ve made at forks in their own roads. Everyone has a bit of shameful baggage, so the combination of this ghostlike figure and the poem indicated many possible targets to me.
Then Reine-Marie discovers a body, and what had been just nervous curiosity about the hooded person becomes a murder investigation.
Isabelle Lacoste is now the head of homicide for the Sûreté, Gamache’s old job, and she takes charge . . . but she keeps a close eye on him.
“Then her gaze moved on to Monsieur Gamache.
His hands were clasped behind his back and he was staring out the window. A less astute observer might think he’d lost interest. But Lacoste could see, even in profile, the intense focus of the man. Listening closely to every word, every inflection.
He often said that words told them what someone was thinking, but the tone told them how they felt.”
Gamache has quite a moral dilemma as he weighs up his personal responsibilities against the greater good, so it’s fascinating to watch him speaking in court and thinking carefully about what he knows and what he will say.
The author’s note at the end explains that she made up some of the background (I did so want it to be true!), but mostly, I’m just glad to know I have more of this series to look forward to.
“And that’s what the chief explored. Elusive, volatile, unpredictable, often dangerous feelings. Searching out that one raw, wild emotion. That led to murder.”
Two timelines over two seasons, one during late autumn in the small Canadian village of Three Pines, and one in the sweltering summer of a Montreal courtroom with broken air conditioning. Louise Penny does the heat of a summer's day in close quarters as well as she does blustery cold in a remote, dark forest at night.
The book opens in a hot, crowded, Montreal courtroom:
“‘State your name, please.’
‘Armand Gamache.’
‘And you are the head of the Sûreté du Québec?’
‘The Chief Superintendent, oui.’ ”
Gamache has risen to the top of the Québec police force, which he has just cleaned out and is gradually restaffing. He thinks they have almost completely lost the War Against Drugs, as it is so often called, and he despairs for the thousands of families who are being torn apart as their children succumb to Fentanyl and the like.
He is determined to make a last-ditch effort to blow up the cartels. So why is he on the witness stand being questioned in a hostile manner by the Chief Crown Prosecutor?
Penny has chosen not to write this as a dual timeline or with alternating chapters. In answer to a question on Goodreads, she says:
“I didn’t want to fall into the easy formula of having one chapter past, next in the present. I wanted it to feel like it does in real life….where we often have our minds in both places. Standing in the present but reliving the past. Without a border. Slipping back and forth.”
https://www.goodreads.com/notes/34223...
So why is Gamache testifying and to what? His mind goes back to the previous autumn in Three Pines, the tiny village to which he and his beloved wife, Reine-Marie, have retired. Retired until he took up this new position, that is. He discovered it when investigating a murder many years ago.
“Few could find Three Pines, hidden in the valley, and that included the satellites that provided Internet coverage for most of the planet. The village was civilization adjacent. The information superhighway zoomed overhead. And Three Pines was a pothole.”
Readers of previous books in the series know the charm of Three Pines and the community of which so many of us have become fond. And the food, which we all drool over. Our favourite characters are there, along with some newcomers – an assistant at the bakery and a guy who fancies himself a chef but who’s washing dishes in the bistro.
Then there’s a group of friends who usually holiday here together in the summer but have moved their visit to autumn. One is a well-known politician now, but all have been friends since university days.
The Three Pines section begins on Halloween, October 31, at a party, where a strange figure has appeared and then disappeared. Whoever it was wore a dark coat with a hood up in such a way that nobody noticed the face. Later, the figure just stood still in the Village Green for hours on end, seemingly haunting ‘someone’ by simply standing and staring in a particular direction.
We’re told a story about the possible significance of this stalking, but nobody has any idea what the purpose is or who the target is. It does appear to suggest that someone who has been wronged is seeking retribution. A kind of living conscience.
Ruth is a cranky, foul-mouthed 80-year-old, who is also a poet. Occasionally we are treated to a bit of it, and these few lines are quoted more than once.
“From the public school to the private hell
of the family masquerade,
Where could a boy on a bicycle go
when the straight road splayed?”
This pricks the consciences of some of the men, who muse privately about the choices they’ve made at forks in their own roads. Everyone has a bit of shameful baggage, so the combination of this ghostlike figure and the poem indicated many possible targets to me.
Then Reine-Marie discovers a body, and what had been just nervous curiosity about the hooded person becomes a murder investigation.
Isabelle Lacoste is now the head of homicide for the Sûreté, Gamache’s old job, and she takes charge . . . but she keeps a close eye on him.
“Then her gaze moved on to Monsieur Gamache.
His hands were clasped behind his back and he was staring out the window. A less astute observer might think he’d lost interest. But Lacoste could see, even in profile, the intense focus of the man. Listening closely to every word, every inflection.
He often said that words told them what someone was thinking, but the tone told them how they felt.”
Gamache has quite a moral dilemma as he weighs up his personal responsibilities against the greater good, so it’s fascinating to watch him speaking in court and thinking carefully about what he knows and what he will say.
The author’s note at the end explains that she made up some of the background (I did so want it to be true!), but mostly, I’m just glad to know I have more of this series to look forward to.
August 24, 2018
I am going to give this one five stars. Out of the thirteen books so far in this series this has to be one of the best.
Since the last book Armand Gamache has moved on to higher things and now he is Chief Superintendent of the Quebec police. Glass Houses commences in court with Armand giving evidence against an accused murderer. In Penny's usual fashion she makes the reader wait for most of the book to find out who this murderer is. In fact we spend a lot of the time in the dark as Penny and Gamache dole out information in tiny increments.
The story is excellent and all of our favourite characters appear at some point. Ruth and Reine Marie have larger roles than usual, but Rosa only gets to say her usual one word. The ending is huge and the repercussions may be very interesting. We will have to wait until the next book to find out.
Since the last book Armand Gamache has moved on to higher things and now he is Chief Superintendent of the Quebec police. Glass Houses commences in court with Armand giving evidence against an accused murderer. In Penny's usual fashion she makes the reader wait for most of the book to find out who this murderer is. In fact we spend a lot of the time in the dark as Penny and Gamache dole out information in tiny increments.
The story is excellent and all of our favourite characters appear at some point. Ruth and Reine Marie have larger roles than usual, but Rosa only gets to say her usual one word. The ending is huge and the repercussions may be very interesting. We will have to wait until the next book to find out.
October 29, 2017
I was so very excited when I found this book on my holds shelf at the library. I ran through the first 100 pages and then found my lovely wife was diagnosed with breast cancer. I couldn't find the time nor the desire to pick up this book, I believe because I almost felt guilty reading this brilliance while my wife suffered through surgeries and then started chemo. I travelled this past week for work and enjoyed this book like the rest of Penny's masterpieces. I've paid a month's late fees (I should have just bought the book)!
I am definitely on the short list of Louise Penny's best fans! Truly she is brilliant and her books are works of art!
The good news is my wife caught her breast cancer early and after a crappy year her prognosis will look great.
I am definitely on the short list of Louise Penny's best fans! Truly she is brilliant and her books are works of art!
The good news is my wife caught her breast cancer early and after a crappy year her prognosis will look great.
September 23, 2019
I think this might be one of the best yet in this series. It's a bit of a slow burner and should definitely not be tackled unless you have read the rest of the series as you really need to be familiar with the village of Three Pines and those who live there to get the most out of it.
After cleaning out the corruption from the Sûreté de Quebec's training Academie, Chief Inspector Armand Gamache has accepted the job as Chief Superintendent of the Sûreté. He realises that the police are losing the battle against major crime, despite small wins now and again. He gathers those he can trust around him and plans to play a long game that will either be a spectacular success or result in dismal failure and disgrace.
Meanwhile in the village of Three Pines, a person dressed and masked entirely in black is standing day after day without moving in the centre of the village green and unnerving all the residents. Called a Cobrador, the person acts as a conscience for the guilty person they are following, goading them into confessing and repenting just by refusing to go away until they do. When someone dressed as a Cobrador is murdered, a murder team headed by Isabel Lacoste is called into the village to investigate.
These two threads of the novel are related in parallel with Gamache attending the trial of the person accused of the murder and relating past events while meeting with his team to plan their strike against major crime. Lousie Penny is very good at expertly pacing her books so that information is released in a slow but intriguing trickle and the first half of the novel is slow as the scene is set. However, rest assured it will all come together in a huge, explosive finish that will have major repercussions for all involved. All the well loved characters from Three Pines are involved in the events and it's always a delight to spend time with them and get to know them a bit better.
After cleaning out the corruption from the Sûreté de Quebec's training Academie, Chief Inspector Armand Gamache has accepted the job as Chief Superintendent of the Sûreté. He realises that the police are losing the battle against major crime, despite small wins now and again. He gathers those he can trust around him and plans to play a long game that will either be a spectacular success or result in dismal failure and disgrace.
Meanwhile in the village of Three Pines, a person dressed and masked entirely in black is standing day after day without moving in the centre of the village green and unnerving all the residents. Called a Cobrador, the person acts as a conscience for the guilty person they are following, goading them into confessing and repenting just by refusing to go away until they do. When someone dressed as a Cobrador is murdered, a murder team headed by Isabel Lacoste is called into the village to investigate.
These two threads of the novel are related in parallel with Gamache attending the trial of the person accused of the murder and relating past events while meeting with his team to plan their strike against major crime. Lousie Penny is very good at expertly pacing her books so that information is released in a slow but intriguing trickle and the first half of the novel is slow as the scene is set. However, rest assured it will all come together in a huge, explosive finish that will have major repercussions for all involved. All the well loved characters from Three Pines are involved in the events and it's always a delight to spend time with them and get to know them a bit better.
November 1, 2019
The Halloween party had most of Three Pines’ residents present so the stranger stood out. But it was the following morning when that same stranger was spotted, standing completely still, watching the village. As emotions escalated between the residents, Armand Gamache, newly in the position of Chief Superintendent of the Sûreté du Québec, was wary. Within two days the figure, masked and dressed in black, had vanished and hours later a body was discovered…
Gamache, Jean-Guy Beauvoir and Isabel Lacoste dug deeply into the mystery; they needed justice for the victim. But was there more going on than it seemed?
Eight months later, Gamache was on the stand in court, being questioned relentlessly about the case. The courtroom was hot, stuffy and filled with eager listeners. What would be the outcome? Would the accused be found guilty?
Absolutely brilliant! Glass Houses is the 13th in the Chief Inspector Armand Gamache series and dare I say, I feel it’s Louise Penny’s best yet! The easy flow of court case and events at Three Pines seemed effortless. The comments from my favourite character, Ruth Zardo, had me laughing out loud on occasion. The twists and turns kept me turning the pages well into the night and it was with great satisfaction that I turned the last page. The author’s notes at the end are both heartbreaking and intriguing. I’m loving this series and will be sad to be up to date. Highly recommended.
Gamache, Jean-Guy Beauvoir and Isabel Lacoste dug deeply into the mystery; they needed justice for the victim. But was there more going on than it seemed?
Eight months later, Gamache was on the stand in court, being questioned relentlessly about the case. The courtroom was hot, stuffy and filled with eager listeners. What would be the outcome? Would the accused be found guilty?
Absolutely brilliant! Glass Houses is the 13th in the Chief Inspector Armand Gamache series and dare I say, I feel it’s Louise Penny’s best yet! The easy flow of court case and events at Three Pines seemed effortless. The comments from my favourite character, Ruth Zardo, had me laughing out loud on occasion. The twists and turns kept me turning the pages well into the night and it was with great satisfaction that I turned the last page. The author’s notes at the end are both heartbreaking and intriguing. I’m loving this series and will be sad to be up to date. Highly recommended.
February 3, 2018
I'm attached to this series. I like the Three Pines and Sûreté du Québec regulars.
I know, a drunken old poet, an untidy artist, a charming gay couple that run a B&B. Just don't tell the cliche police. Ruth and the Archangels were great.
Like a lot of good readers, I was as interested in Louise Penny's personal loss as her latest novel. Still Life came out in 2005, but a feel like I've known her longer.
I know, a drunken old poet, an untidy artist, a charming gay couple that run a B&B. Just don't tell the cliche police. Ruth and the Archangels were great.
Like a lot of good readers, I was as interested in Louise Penny's personal loss as her latest novel. Still Life came out in 2005, but a feel like I've known her longer.
Whitehead, (Dr.) Victor Michael B.A., M.A., M.D.C.M., C.S.P.Q., F.R.C.P.C (born April 10, 1934), was called to Glory on September 18, 2016, after a breathtakingly, achingly valiant and dignified battle with dementia. He died at home, surrounded by all the love he'd given to others in his 82 years. Predeceased by his parents, George Victor and Doris (Jack), his brother Edward and sister Carol (Lloyd-Jones), and his first wife, Sheilagh (Ryan). Michael leaves behind his wife Louise (Penny), his sons, Michael, Richard (Kathy) and Victor, two grandchildren and countless friends...
http://www.legacy.com/obituaries/sher...
January 11, 2024
It is the end of the first half of the year in most school districts. This week I have had the luxury of watching kids finish up independent work while I sit and read. As much as I enjoy teaching kids of all ages, being able to read and work with kids is an added perk of the profession. My primary role this week has been in a junior high and I have caught snatches of conversations about binge watching. I have never been one to binge watch, but I have binge read over the years, most often concerning mystery series. Louise Penny’s Armand Gamache is the best of best concerning modern police detectives. He is a modern Hercule Poirot, with added passion, grace, and a family. Most long running series become stagnant with some books worse than others, but with Penny’s adept skill and ability to craft a community out of her characters, Gamache’s stories have become better with each passing book. While I am one to savor my time in Penny’s world, I could not resist a trip to Three Pines, forgetting my own pressing issues and immersing myself in those of these remarkable characters.
Armand Gamache is the new Chief Superintendent of the Sureté, after successfully weeding out the corruption permeating the Academy. He is joined by his son-in-law Jean Guy Beauvoir while keeping Isabel LaCoste as Chief Inspector of homicide and installing Madeleine Toussiant as Chief Inspector on the war against drugs. The Sureté is in a better place because of Gamache’s manipulating, all but eliminating the graft present under Sylvain LeCoeur. Although Gamache accepted the position, he still chooses to make his home in Three Pines rather than Montreal because Three Pines is home and the villagers have grown to become family. At a gathering for drinks at the Bistro, Myrna suggests that one’s closest friends have been present throughout many lifetimes. Lacoste suggests that Gamache and Beauvoir are the ultimate “kahootites”, having been together as father and son or perhaps as brothers across the millennia. Gamache has a son and daughter of his own, but Beauvoir and Lacoste have always been his children. While this has been evident in earlier books in the series, it becomes all the more so here, as Gamache’s war against drugs threatens to tear apart families, with the memory of Beauvoir’s own addiction permeating the surface. The Sureté is fighting this continued war on drugs so that additional families are not broken apart by addition and that Quebec provides a safer life for new generations of children.
Three Pines is not a normal place. Murders just seem to happen there. The village is where people go to find a safe haven, yet once a year, the simplicity of this life is disrupted by murder. Beauvoir and Lacoste are such regulars in the village that Ruth Zardo, poet laureate and old hag, calls him by her own special nickname. Ruth, Clara, Myrna, Olivier, and Gabri, and, of course, Reine Marie have been parts of many a murder investigation, at this point knowing how to answer pointed questions and deflect the advances of villagers searching for information. One day while at the bistro a Spanish cobrador, a debt collector, appears on the village green. Villagers feel spooked and want it to leave. Beauvoir’s research leads him to a seven hundred year history of the cobrador, finding out that it originated during the times of the black plague. While the modern version is a debt collector, the centuries old cobrador is a conscience, pleading with victims to apology or destroy their lives. We find out that everyone has some debt to pay to a higher conscience. This becomes all the more poignant when the cobrador supposedly kills a visitor to the village, and it is Madame Gamache who finds the body in the cellar of the village church. The peace that Three Pines provides for people looking for a second chance in life is about to be put to the ultimate test.
Penny begins the book with Gamache as a key witness in the murder trial. Each chapter goes back and forth between the murder investigation, war on drugs, and the trial that ties the threads together. Penny has Gamache play the roles of Atticus Finch, Gandhi, and Poirot all in the same case. While he appeals to Quebecois to submit to a higher conscience, he also needs to balance this conscience with the letter of the law, something that at times is difficult to uphold. While a murderer is on trial, the Sureté continues to wage a war against opioid addiction. It is not an easy topic to digest, and many readers stated that they could not read this entire case, thereby downgrading it as compared to other books in the series. Glass Houses brought out Penny’s skills as a writer. She introduced multiple new characters, most of them being women who shattered the glass ceiling: Judge Maureen Corriveau, Chief Inspector Madeleine Toussiant, and rising politician Lea Roux. Along with Lacoste, Reine Marie, et al, Penny demonstrates how women play a vital role in all aspects of society, all the more so going forward into the 21st century. It is both women’s sharp thinking skills, artistic depth, and savvy that play a vital role in all the threads in this novel.
Gamache plays his role as Poirot best in this novel as he eventually wraps up the trial and drug war but at a great personal cost to himself and those near and dear to him. Penny wrote this book after her husband passed away from dementia. She entered the world of Three Pines to stem the grief she felt on a daily basis. Dementia affects nearly as many families as drug usage, and Penny’s husband dealt with his diagnosis with dignity and grace. Three Pines may not be as much as a safe haven as it was before this case; however, Penny provides more depth of the village’s unique history, placing the village as an escape for people of all walks of life, the Gamaches included. Three Pines is indeed family for both the writer and the reader. I look forward to my next trip to the village.
4.5 stars
Armand Gamache is the new Chief Superintendent of the Sureté, after successfully weeding out the corruption permeating the Academy. He is joined by his son-in-law Jean Guy Beauvoir while keeping Isabel LaCoste as Chief Inspector of homicide and installing Madeleine Toussiant as Chief Inspector on the war against drugs. The Sureté is in a better place because of Gamache’s manipulating, all but eliminating the graft present under Sylvain LeCoeur. Although Gamache accepted the position, he still chooses to make his home in Three Pines rather than Montreal because Three Pines is home and the villagers have grown to become family. At a gathering for drinks at the Bistro, Myrna suggests that one’s closest friends have been present throughout many lifetimes. Lacoste suggests that Gamache and Beauvoir are the ultimate “kahootites”, having been together as father and son or perhaps as brothers across the millennia. Gamache has a son and daughter of his own, but Beauvoir and Lacoste have always been his children. While this has been evident in earlier books in the series, it becomes all the more so here, as Gamache’s war against drugs threatens to tear apart families, with the memory of Beauvoir’s own addiction permeating the surface. The Sureté is fighting this continued war on drugs so that additional families are not broken apart by addition and that Quebec provides a safer life for new generations of children.
Three Pines is not a normal place. Murders just seem to happen there. The village is where people go to find a safe haven, yet once a year, the simplicity of this life is disrupted by murder. Beauvoir and Lacoste are such regulars in the village that Ruth Zardo, poet laureate and old hag, calls him by her own special nickname. Ruth, Clara, Myrna, Olivier, and Gabri, and, of course, Reine Marie have been parts of many a murder investigation, at this point knowing how to answer pointed questions and deflect the advances of villagers searching for information. One day while at the bistro a Spanish cobrador, a debt collector, appears on the village green. Villagers feel spooked and want it to leave. Beauvoir’s research leads him to a seven hundred year history of the cobrador, finding out that it originated during the times of the black plague. While the modern version is a debt collector, the centuries old cobrador is a conscience, pleading with victims to apology or destroy their lives. We find out that everyone has some debt to pay to a higher conscience. This becomes all the more poignant when the cobrador supposedly kills a visitor to the village, and it is Madame Gamache who finds the body in the cellar of the village church. The peace that Three Pines provides for people looking for a second chance in life is about to be put to the ultimate test.
Penny begins the book with Gamache as a key witness in the murder trial. Each chapter goes back and forth between the murder investigation, war on drugs, and the trial that ties the threads together. Penny has Gamache play the roles of Atticus Finch, Gandhi, and Poirot all in the same case. While he appeals to Quebecois to submit to a higher conscience, he also needs to balance this conscience with the letter of the law, something that at times is difficult to uphold. While a murderer is on trial, the Sureté continues to wage a war against opioid addiction. It is not an easy topic to digest, and many readers stated that they could not read this entire case, thereby downgrading it as compared to other books in the series. Glass Houses brought out Penny’s skills as a writer. She introduced multiple new characters, most of them being women who shattered the glass ceiling: Judge Maureen Corriveau, Chief Inspector Madeleine Toussiant, and rising politician Lea Roux. Along with Lacoste, Reine Marie, et al, Penny demonstrates how women play a vital role in all aspects of society, all the more so going forward into the 21st century. It is both women’s sharp thinking skills, artistic depth, and savvy that play a vital role in all the threads in this novel.
Gamache plays his role as Poirot best in this novel as he eventually wraps up the trial and drug war but at a great personal cost to himself and those near and dear to him. Penny wrote this book after her husband passed away from dementia. She entered the world of Three Pines to stem the grief she felt on a daily basis. Dementia affects nearly as many families as drug usage, and Penny’s husband dealt with his diagnosis with dignity and grace. Three Pines may not be as much as a safe haven as it was before this case; however, Penny provides more depth of the village’s unique history, placing the village as an escape for people of all walks of life, the Gamaches included. Three Pines is indeed family for both the writer and the reader. I look forward to my next trip to the village.
4.5 stars
December 24, 2017
SUMMARY
It was the month of November. Conscience, the Cobrador, entered Three Pines, and with the unseemly rainy, sleety weather for days, which seemed to seep right through the clothing, skin and pooled in the bones, quarrels broke out in the bistro over trivial things. They haven't seen the sun for days, felt like weeks, months, perhaps forever. Guests and inhabitants alike were stressed, the nerves frayed, tempers short.
Someone in Three Pines did something so horrific that a Conscience had to be called. He was standing there on the village green, not moving, talking, or budging. "No man is as bad as the worst thing he has done."
Then someone died and Chief Superintendent Inspector Armand Gamache, head of the Sûreté du Québec had to relate the events in court to the young new judge Maureen Corriveau. It was her first homicide case. People were nervous, and Conscience stood witness to the proceedings. The murderer was already known. The pompous Crown, Barry Zalmanowitz, made it his mission to grind Gamache into the woodwork as though he was the defendant instead of a witness.
It was not a cut and dry case at all. Buddhists or Toaists said that there are certain people we meet time and and time again, in different lifetimes. Take for instance the resident poet Ruth with her doppelgänger, Rosa the duck. The duck might have been her child in a past life. The more time passes, the more they looked the same. Ruth, with her potty mouth and the duck that reply fuck fuck fuck to everything that comes out of Ruth's mouth.
And then there was the issue of Cobradors del frac from ancient Spanish times, that might have passed from the Old World into the New World, into the beloved Three Pines residence's world. We all know the residents so well: Clara Morrow, the hugely successful portrait artist; Dr. Myrna Landers, the retired psychologist and now owner of The New And Used Bookstore right next to the Bistro; Gabri Dubeau, who ran the local B&B with his partner Olivier; Katie and Patrick Evans, the contractor and his architect wife who build glass houses; Jacqueline and Sarah from the bakery (in her world a good baguette was a magic wand that solved all problems); Anton, the new dishwasher and bus at the bistro; guests Matheo Bissonette and his wife Lea Roux, the member of the National Assembly, old friends of the Evanses; and the rest of Three Pines.
It all became weird with that Halloween party in the Bistro, when Gamache thought the person in the black costume looked like Death...
In the ensuing court case, Gamache had to maneuver through the collusion between magic and reality to conclude the events that shook the small Canadian village. Still the murder capital of Canada. Now Armand and his wife Reine-Marie were permanent residence as well. In his quest for peace and quiet, trying to escape the vile, the tragic and the terrifying world of crime, Gamache became more than just the chief of police. He became one of them. And sometimes being a friend, and being a policeman might not gel. Things could fall in place or fall apart this time, especially when he discovered that all drug smuggling routes converged in this village which did not even appear on a map. He was determined to strike a decisive, hard, fast, effective blow right at the heart. He did not believe in a small series of small irritant blows. For this he waited and waited and waited for the right moment...and then the dark figure appeared on the sleet-slashed village green...
They would all have their day in court for what happened next ...
COMMENTS
The author finally defined what made us all so addicted to Three Pines. We all threatened to leave everything and move to Three Pines, Canada. Millions of us want to be part of this unknown, fictitious village with its unique characters.
"Three Pines is a state of mind." she says, " When we choose tolerance over hate. Kindness over cruelty. Goodness over bullying. When we choose to be hopeful, not cynical."
We constantly come back for more of the same. It was a perfect read just before Christmas: a dollop of reality, a big pinch of imagination, mixed with friendship, serious issues and excellent penmanship. Even though it lacked that WOW factor of an excellent murder mystery, felt somewhat contrived, and was not up to par with Penny's previous books, the story did address our need to belong to something, some place better within our own little troubled worlds. There was enough action, mystery and adventure to stick to it if you read it in increments like I did in a very busy holiday season. I was not overly excited about the cliffhanger ending, but there was enough of a denouement to close the book with a song in the heart. I had a Three Pine fix again.
The author wrote this book during her husband's final days and passing. Needless to say, she did a good job despite the difficult time she had to go through. My sincere condolences to her. Louise Penny always add that personal touch to her writing, involving her readers in her stories and her life. It was once again evident in this book. I think it is the reason why we are such devoted followers, even though we might feel annoyed from time to time.
I wish her well. And for all my GR friends, a happy, peaceful season filled with goodness, grace and good memories.
It was the month of November. Conscience, the Cobrador, entered Three Pines, and with the unseemly rainy, sleety weather for days, which seemed to seep right through the clothing, skin and pooled in the bones, quarrels broke out in the bistro over trivial things. They haven't seen the sun for days, felt like weeks, months, perhaps forever. Guests and inhabitants alike were stressed, the nerves frayed, tempers short.
Someone in Three Pines did something so horrific that a Conscience had to be called. He was standing there on the village green, not moving, talking, or budging. "No man is as bad as the worst thing he has done."
Then someone died and Chief Superintendent Inspector Armand Gamache, head of the Sûreté du Québec had to relate the events in court to the young new judge Maureen Corriveau. It was her first homicide case. People were nervous, and Conscience stood witness to the proceedings. The murderer was already known. The pompous Crown, Barry Zalmanowitz, made it his mission to grind Gamache into the woodwork as though he was the defendant instead of a witness.
It was not a cut and dry case at all. Buddhists or Toaists said that there are certain people we meet time and and time again, in different lifetimes. Take for instance the resident poet Ruth with her doppelgänger, Rosa the duck. The duck might have been her child in a past life. The more time passes, the more they looked the same. Ruth, with her potty mouth and the duck that reply fuck fuck fuck to everything that comes out of Ruth's mouth.
And then there was the issue of Cobradors del frac from ancient Spanish times, that might have passed from the Old World into the New World, into the beloved Three Pines residence's world. We all know the residents so well: Clara Morrow, the hugely successful portrait artist; Dr. Myrna Landers, the retired psychologist and now owner of The New And Used Bookstore right next to the Bistro; Gabri Dubeau, who ran the local B&B with his partner Olivier; Katie and Patrick Evans, the contractor and his architect wife who build glass houses; Jacqueline and Sarah from the bakery (in her world a good baguette was a magic wand that solved all problems); Anton, the new dishwasher and bus at the bistro; guests Matheo Bissonette and his wife Lea Roux, the member of the National Assembly, old friends of the Evanses; and the rest of Three Pines.
It all became weird with that Halloween party in the Bistro, when Gamache thought the person in the black costume looked like Death...
In the ensuing court case, Gamache had to maneuver through the collusion between magic and reality to conclude the events that shook the small Canadian village. Still the murder capital of Canada. Now Armand and his wife Reine-Marie were permanent residence as well. In his quest for peace and quiet, trying to escape the vile, the tragic and the terrifying world of crime, Gamache became more than just the chief of police. He became one of them. And sometimes being a friend, and being a policeman might not gel. Things could fall in place or fall apart this time, especially when he discovered that all drug smuggling routes converged in this village which did not even appear on a map. He was determined to strike a decisive, hard, fast, effective blow right at the heart. He did not believe in a small series of small irritant blows. For this he waited and waited and waited for the right moment...and then the dark figure appeared on the sleet-slashed village green...
They would all have their day in court for what happened next ...
COMMENTS
The author finally defined what made us all so addicted to Three Pines. We all threatened to leave everything and move to Three Pines, Canada. Millions of us want to be part of this unknown, fictitious village with its unique characters.
"Three Pines is a state of mind." she says, " When we choose tolerance over hate. Kindness over cruelty. Goodness over bullying. When we choose to be hopeful, not cynical."
We constantly come back for more of the same. It was a perfect read just before Christmas: a dollop of reality, a big pinch of imagination, mixed with friendship, serious issues and excellent penmanship. Even though it lacked that WOW factor of an excellent murder mystery, felt somewhat contrived, and was not up to par with Penny's previous books, the story did address our need to belong to something, some place better within our own little troubled worlds. There was enough action, mystery and adventure to stick to it if you read it in increments like I did in a very busy holiday season. I was not overly excited about the cliffhanger ending, but there was enough of a denouement to close the book with a song in the heart. I had a Three Pine fix again.
The author wrote this book during her husband's final days and passing. Needless to say, she did a good job despite the difficult time she had to go through. My sincere condolences to her. Louise Penny always add that personal touch to her writing, involving her readers in her stories and her life. It was once again evident in this book. I think it is the reason why we are such devoted followers, even though we might feel annoyed from time to time.
I wish her well. And for all my GR friends, a happy, peaceful season filled with goodness, grace and good memories.
April 22, 2023
Decimotercera novela de la serie protagonizada por Armando Gamache, ahora ascendido a Superintendente Jefe de la Sûreté du Québec.
La novela se inicia con Gamache declarando en un juicio por asesinato que se liga a una investigación de tráfico de drogas, y la historia está contada en tres tiempos: antes del juicio, durante y después.
La autora tiene una pluma muy elegante y fluida que teje una historia llena de tensión y suspense con unos personajes que tienen una personalidad compleja y atractiva.
Y el pueblecito de Three Pines es un pueblecito encantador al que dan ganas de mudarse, aunque luego ocurran allí cosas tremendas.
La novela se inicia con Gamache declarando en un juicio por asesinato que se liga a una investigación de tráfico de drogas, y la historia está contada en tres tiempos: antes del juicio, durante y después.
La autora tiene una pluma muy elegante y fluida que teje una historia llena de tensión y suspense con unos personajes que tienen una personalidad compleja y atractiva.
Y el pueblecito de Three Pines es un pueblecito encantador al que dan ganas de mudarse, aunque luego ocurran allí cosas tremendas.
April 9, 2018
I didn't think i could be surprised by our dear author again, but my God was i surprised and nicely so ;
Gamache crossed a big line ! Our beloved police chief applied the famous saying that "the end justifies the means" by letting thousands of people die in order to draw the evil to him and cut his head so to speak , it was a huge gamble for him: everyone was turning against him and the popo ... It was an incredible story and as always three pines is at the center of it ... A very suspenseful tale, flash-back style ......
On a sad note my deepest sympathy to Ms P : may your husband find peace in the afterlife.
Gamache crossed a big line ! Our beloved police chief applied the famous saying that "the end justifies the means" by letting thousands of people die in order to draw the evil to him and cut his head so to speak , it was a huge gamble for him: everyone was turning against him and the popo ... It was an incredible story and as always three pines is at the center of it ... A very suspenseful tale, flash-back style ......
On a sad note my deepest sympathy to Ms P : may your husband find peace in the afterlife.
September 12, 2017
Rating 2* out 5, that is, a disappointment from what is one of my favorite detective series. Unfortunately, there is something deeply annoying about the way Louise Penny writes that I struggle to see beyond.
"This was closer than she'd ever been to him, and for a more sustained length of time. The deep scar at his temple was still tehere, and always would be, of course. As though the job had branded him. Close up, she could see the lines radiating from his mouth. And eyes. Life lines. Laugh lines, she knew. She had them too."
The wise Gamache, superintendent, is lying to the court at a murder trial. The trial plot line is intertwined with the murder plot line, being further into the past. Four friends come for their regular reunion in Three Pines. A mysterious figure in black shows up. One of the friends, Katie, ends up dead.
At the same time, Gamache is trying to do something about the run away drug problems. Ugh. Had I known about this, I would not have bought the book. "Drug cartel" and "mafia" usually means I take a pass, with the fewest of exceptions that I always regret. I definitely regret reading this. I am so tired of the saintly, wise Gamache and even the lovely villagers of Three Pines could not put me in a good mood. I've spent a week trying not to read. This is definitely my last Louise Penny book. At least for a year, by next August and the inevitable next installment I may have forgotten my stance.
"This was closer than she'd ever been to him, and for a more sustained length of time. The deep scar at his temple was still tehere, and always would be, of course. As though the job had branded him. Close up, she could see the lines radiating from his mouth. And eyes. Life lines. Laugh lines, she knew. She had them too."
The wise Gamache, superintendent, is lying to the court at a murder trial. The trial plot line is intertwined with the murder plot line, being further into the past. Four friends come for their regular reunion in Three Pines. A mysterious figure in black shows up. One of the friends, Katie, ends up dead.
At the same time, Gamache is trying to do something about the run away drug problems. Ugh. Had I known about this, I would not have bought the book. "Drug cartel" and "mafia" usually means I take a pass, with the fewest of exceptions that I always regret. I definitely regret reading this. I am so tired of the saintly, wise Gamache and even the lovely villagers of Three Pines could not put me in a good mood. I've spent a week trying not to read. This is definitely my last Louise Penny book. At least for a year, by next August and the inevitable next installment I may have forgotten my stance.
January 31, 2020
Everyone who seems to "know" me here has read me saying over and over how I absolutely am horrible at following a series. This is proof. Random library pick. #13 book of the Armand Gamache series. Never read a book by Penny and here I go picking up #13. And I liked it. A lot.
There were waaaayyy too many characters though, but I get it. He's a cop and it happened in his village with people he knows.
It was a bit farfetched with stopping the cartels entirely but she made the storyline work. I was invested in these characters and I want more Loiuse Penny in my literary life.
There were waaaayyy too many characters though, but I get it. He's a cop and it happened in his village with people he knows.
It was a bit farfetched with stopping the cartels entirely but she made the storyline work. I was invested in these characters and I want more Loiuse Penny in my literary life.
August 15, 2017
Brilliant.
Unique to the series, Glass Houses opens with Armand Gamache on the witness stand giving evidence in a murder trial. It is July and the courtroom is stifling hot. His recounting of the events which led to a murder in Three Pines the previous November bring chills to those in the courtroom. Armand is often interrupted by the prosecuting attorney and his actions leading up to the murder are questioned. It becomes apparent to the judge that all is not as it appears. Gamache is a witness for the Crown. Why then is the Chief Crown Prosecutor baiting his own witness?
I admit to struggling with the opening format as scenes in the present fold into memories from the past. Once the story gets rolling and some new characters begin blending with the fabric that is Three Pines I had no trouble finding my place by the fire in the Bistro, fully engaged and eager to learn. And learn I did.
Glass Houses is a masterpiece. It is far more than a simple murder mystery. It is a work of art. We have the usual beautiful prose we’ve come to expect from novels penned by this author. She adds details and quotes which sent this reader off to research, hoping to understand, with deeper analysis, what is going on in the hearts and minds of the speakers. Penny doesn’t write over the heads of her readers. Instead she invites us to dig a little deeper into our own perceptions and our views of the human condition.
The author softens the deep and profound with moments of humour. When Gamache looks at his dog Henri he ponders how the dog keeps everything important in his heart and cookies in his head. The Three Pines gang slip into their expected roles and add light to what is often a very dark read. She refers to Ruth as “the verbal speed bump that was the old poet”.
So, what is this book about? As the title implies, can you criticize the bad qualities in others when your yourself are not perfect? Glass Houses looks at acts of conscience and acts of terror. The actions caused by fear over facts. It is impossible not to equate the fictional with our own current political realities. It makes for a powerful essay on the danger someone acting “in good conscience” can have on society.
It is a powerful read.
5 stars only scrapes the surface.
ARC received with thanks from Minotaur Books and St. Martin’s Press via NetGalley for review.
Unique to the series, Glass Houses opens with Armand Gamache on the witness stand giving evidence in a murder trial. It is July and the courtroom is stifling hot. His recounting of the events which led to a murder in Three Pines the previous November bring chills to those in the courtroom. Armand is often interrupted by the prosecuting attorney and his actions leading up to the murder are questioned. It becomes apparent to the judge that all is not as it appears. Gamache is a witness for the Crown. Why then is the Chief Crown Prosecutor baiting his own witness?
I admit to struggling with the opening format as scenes in the present fold into memories from the past. Once the story gets rolling and some new characters begin blending with the fabric that is Three Pines I had no trouble finding my place by the fire in the Bistro, fully engaged and eager to learn. And learn I did.
Glass Houses is a masterpiece. It is far more than a simple murder mystery. It is a work of art. We have the usual beautiful prose we’ve come to expect from novels penned by this author. She adds details and quotes which sent this reader off to research, hoping to understand, with deeper analysis, what is going on in the hearts and minds of the speakers. Penny doesn’t write over the heads of her readers. Instead she invites us to dig a little deeper into our own perceptions and our views of the human condition.
The author softens the deep and profound with moments of humour. When Gamache looks at his dog Henri he ponders how the dog keeps everything important in his heart and cookies in his head. The Three Pines gang slip into their expected roles and add light to what is often a very dark read. She refers to Ruth as “the verbal speed bump that was the old poet”.
So, what is this book about? As the title implies, can you criticize the bad qualities in others when your yourself are not perfect? Glass Houses looks at acts of conscience and acts of terror. The actions caused by fear over facts. It is impossible not to equate the fictional with our own current political realities. It makes for a powerful essay on the danger someone acting “in good conscience” can have on society.
It is a powerful read.
5 stars only scrapes the surface.
ARC received with thanks from Minotaur Books and St. Martin’s Press via NetGalley for review.
August 30, 2017
A conscience - we all have one, but do we know what may be on another person's conscience or even on ours that may bother us?
When a hooded figure appeared on the green in Three Pines and stayed without moving for three days, all the residents were tense and wondered what he was doing there. Did the hooded figure date back to the historical Cobrador who collected debts?
Armand Gamache, Chief Inspector, kept an eye on the figure and could do nothing within his powers to remove him. But...why is Armand Gamache now on the witness stand testifying about a death that occurred during the time the hooded figure was present?
We follow the situation by being introduced to the trial and then back again to the events in Three Pines with the hooded figure standing on the village green. The trial has something going on besides the trial, though, and the judge seems to be picking up on it.
Louise Penny has given us another beautifully written, intellectual, intriguing plot that will have you glued to the pages, thinking about what a conscience really is and how it helps or hinders one's choices, and feeling for Gamache as he must defend all that happened in the quiet village of Three Pines.
GLASS HOUSES had me confused during the first few chapters, but once GLASS HOUSES got going another fantastic Louise Penny read and outcome awaits you with the endings always being brilliant and unexpected.
Don't miss reading the latest from Louise Penny. 4/5
This book was given to me free of charge and without compensation by the publisher in return for an honest review.
April 4, 2024
Catching up…
Although it appears that I am reading books backwards, having recently read and reviewed “A Better Man,” I actually did read this one when it first came out. It was “A Better Man” that I hadn’t read until recently. I am now finally re-visiting this one and posting my reviews for Goodreads.
Glass Houses starts in an unusual place. With Gamache in the role as Chief Superintendent of the Surete du Quebec and in the witness box being questioned about a murder that took place in Three Pines a few months back.
And while he is being questioned on the stand, readers are being taken back to earlier when the story supposedly took place. Because, at this point, as readers, we have no idea who was murdered. Or who was the murderer.
We just know that there is something dark happening.
Penny has a way of creating a scene with short sentences and paragraphs and stylistic characters that keep readers entranced. What exactly happened? We need to know.
And before long we do. And everything is changed. And nothing would be the same again.
If readers are up for the slow burn, they will appreciate the clear focus of the explosive ending.
Although it appears that I am reading books backwards, having recently read and reviewed “A Better Man,” I actually did read this one when it first came out. It was “A Better Man” that I hadn’t read until recently. I am now finally re-visiting this one and posting my reviews for Goodreads.
Glass Houses starts in an unusual place. With Gamache in the role as Chief Superintendent of the Surete du Quebec and in the witness box being questioned about a murder that took place in Three Pines a few months back.
And while he is being questioned on the stand, readers are being taken back to earlier when the story supposedly took place. Because, at this point, as readers, we have no idea who was murdered. Or who was the murderer.
We just know that there is something dark happening.
Penny has a way of creating a scene with short sentences and paragraphs and stylistic characters that keep readers entranced. What exactly happened? We need to know.
And before long we do. And everything is changed. And nothing would be the same again.
If readers are up for the slow burn, they will appreciate the clear focus of the explosive ending.
February 8, 2020
“How many murders start in the distant past. They have time to fester, to grow. To become malformed and grotesque.”
I have enjoyed almost every book written by Louise Penny. I have come to love the characters and even envy their cozy and peaceful lives in the village.
But Glass Houses was no fun to read.
There was too much embellishment. Too much teasing with too little action. Too much philosophizing. Repetition of the same situations, sometimes the same dialogues. Confusing plot and timelines. Referring to someone by his given name in a sentence and by his surname in the next.
Sometimes I felt like I was reading a children’s dark and grim fairy tale and other times watching a long-drawn-out TV series where you think in each episode something is going to happen, a big revelation… but nothing happens, the episode ends in slow motion while the actors are staring at each other.
“It began as most murders do. Long ago. Though not far away.”
A masked black-robed figure appears in the village of Three Pines bringing along darkness and gloom. He just stands there near the pines, staring, motionless. Who is he? Why is he there?
Then a body is found in the church basement wearing the dark costume. Was the murder premeditated? Was the victim the target all along? Or was it a case of ‘wrong place wrong time’?
I have enjoyed almost every book written by Louise Penny. I have come to love the characters and even envy their cozy and peaceful lives in the village.
But Glass Houses was no fun to read.
There was too much embellishment. Too much teasing with too little action. Too much philosophizing. Repetition of the same situations, sometimes the same dialogues. Confusing plot and timelines. Referring to someone by his given name in a sentence and by his surname in the next.
Sometimes I felt like I was reading a children’s dark and grim fairy tale and other times watching a long-drawn-out TV series where you think in each episode something is going to happen, a big revelation… but nothing happens, the episode ends in slow motion while the actors are staring at each other.
“It began as most murders do. Long ago. Though not far away.”
A masked black-robed figure appears in the village of Three Pines bringing along darkness and gloom. He just stands there near the pines, staring, motionless. Who is he? Why is he there?
Then a body is found in the church basement wearing the dark costume. Was the murder premeditated? Was the victim the target all along? Or was it a case of ‘wrong place wrong time’?
Displaying 1 - 30 of 6,690 reviews